So I am collaborating with a vocalist/songwriter – she writes on ukulele and then transcribes to piano by going note for note and putting into the Logic piano roll
However, it seems whenever she sends me Logic projects, the notes and chords are never in a particular key (for example, she sent me one earlier where the closest key (6 of the 8 notes she played) being Bb Hungarian minor)
While it doesn’t sound bad , am I wrong in thinking that it would sound better if transposed up to A melodic minor?
I sent her the project after converting it to A melodic minor (which really only changed 2 notes IIRC) and she said it did not sound “right”
Is this once again a situation where, if it sounds good, it is good?
Am I being too rigid?